Elder Board: Current members of the Elder Board are Galen Burleigh, Brad Brautigam, Karl Kimball, Bruce McMordie, Duane Smulling, and Doug Wesney.  Elders rotate on and off the Elder Board, serving no more than two consecutive 3-year terms.
Associate Pastor Bruce Finn serves as the moderator of the Board. Executive Pastor Rob Bloss is an ex-officio member.

Shepherding Elders: Elders not serving a term on the Elder Board serve as Shepherding Elders and are focused exclusively on providing for the spiritual care and growth of the members of Covenant. They are Jon Gindhart, Glenn Longmuir, Greg Michael, Mark Pappas, Larry Rankin, Kevin Sheetz, Matt Toll and Sam Totaro.